Etsy Email Marketing:

Etsy Email Marketing: Best Practices To Follow

Email marketing is a crucial component of any successful Etsy shop owner’s strategy. It is an effective way to build and maintain relationships with customers, increase sales, and drive traffic to your Etsy shop. However, it’s essential to follow best practices to ensure your email marketing efforts are successful and compliant with Etsy’s policies.

In this guide, we have covered everything you need to know about Etsy email marketing, including how to build your email list, creating effective emails, personalization, and segmentation, timing, and frequency, measuring success, and compliance and best practices.

Building Your Email List

Email marketing campaigns are only as successful as the quality of your email list. Here are some best practices for building an email list that will give you the best possible return on your investment:

Different methods for collecting email addresses

  • Opt-in forms

Opt-in forms are a popular way to collect email addresses from customers who visit your Etsy shop. They can be placed on your shop’s homepage or on product pages to encourage visitors to sign up for your email list.

  • Incentives

Offering incentives like exclusive discounts or freebies is a great way to incentivize customers to join your email list.

Use social media to promote your email list and encourage followers to join.

Best practices for creating an effective opt-in form

  1. Keep it simple: Make your opt-in form easy to fill out by only asking for essential information like name and email address.
  2. Clear call-to-action: Use a clear and concise call-to-action to encourage visitors to sign up for your email list.
  3. Eye-catching design: Make your opt-in form visually appealing with eye-catching colors and fonts that match your brand’s style.

How to incentivize customers to join your list

  1. Exclusive discounts: Offer exclusive discounts to subscribers to incentivize them to join your email list.
  2. Freebies: Offer freebies like eBooks or guides to encourage customers to sign up for your email list.
  3. Early access: Give subscribers early access to new product launches or sales to create a sense of exclusivity and encourage them to sign up for your email list.

Most importantly, always make sure to provide value to your subscribers with relevant and engaging content in every email you send.

Creating Effective Emails

Once you’ve built a quality email list, it’s time to focus on creating engaging and effective email campaigns. Here are some tips for crafting emails that will get your subscribers to take action:

How to craft subject lines that grab attention

Your subject line is the first thing your subscribers will see when they receive your email, so it’s important to make it attention-grabbing. Here’s how:

  1. Keep it short and sweet: Aim for subject lines that are around 50 characters or less.
  2. Use personalization: Including the recipient’s name in the subject line can increase open rates by up to 29%.
  3. Create urgency: Use phrases like “limited time” or “only a few left” to create a sense of urgency and encourage subscribers to open your email.

Tips for creating engaging content

Your email content needs to be engaging and valuable to keep subscribers interested. Here are some tips for creating content that will keep your subscribers reading:

  1. Know your audience: Tailor your content to your specific audience by understanding their needs and interests.
  2. Be informative: Offer helpful tips, advice, or insights that your subscribers will find valuable.
  3. Use storytelling: Tell stories that resonate with your subscribers and connect with them on an emotional level.

Best practices for email design

The design of your email can have a big impact on its effectiveness. Here are some best practices for creating visually appealing emails:

  1. Use a clean layout: Keep your layout simple and easy to read to avoid overwhelming your subscribers.
  2. Include visuals: Use images or videos to break up your content and make your email more visually appealing.
  3. Mobile optimization: Make sure your email is optimized for mobile devices since over 80% of emails are opened on mobile.

Most importantly, always test your emails before sending them to make sure they look and function properly. By following these tips, you can create emails that are engaging, and effective, and drive results for your Etsy shop.

Personalization and Segmentation

Personalization and segmentation can make a huge impact on the effectiveness of your email marketing. By customizing your emails based on customer data and preferences, you can improve engagement and drive more sales.

How to use customer data to personalize emails

Personalizing your emails with customer data can help you stand out from the crowd and increase the chances of a sale. Consider the following tactics:

  • Use the customer’s name in the subject line and opening greeting
  • Recommend products based on their past purchases or browsing history
  • Send targeted messages based on demographics, such as age or location
  • Use dynamic content to show different products or offers based on customer behavior

Best practices for segmenting your email list

Segmenting your email list means dividing it into smaller groups based on shared characteristics. This allows you to send more relevant messages to each group, resulting in higher engagement and conversions. Here are some tips for effective segmentation:

  • Segment by behavior, such as past purchases or engagement with your emails
  • Segment by demographics, such as age, location, or gender
  • Consider using custom tags to further segment your list based on unique characteristics
  • Test different segmentation strategies to see what works best for your audience

How to target specific customer groups with tailored messages

Once you have segmented your email list, you can create targeted messages that are tailored to each group’s interests and needs. This can be done by:

  • Creating specific campaigns for each segment
  • Using language and imagery that resonates with each group
  • Offering promotions or discounts that are tailored to each group’s preferences
  • Testing and refining your messages based on each group’s response

By personalizing your emails and segmenting your list, you can create more effective email campaigns that drive results.

Timing and Frequency

Email timing and frequency can be critical for the success of your Etsy email marketing campaigns. Here are some tips to help you get it right.

Best practices for determining the best time to send emails

The best time to send an email varies depending on the audience and industry. According to research, the best days to send emails are Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday. Furthermore, the best time to send emails is usually between 10 am and 12 pm, or between 2 pm and 4 pm.

How to find the optimal email frequency

Email frequency is a delicate balance between keeping your subscribers engaged and not overwhelming them. It’s crucial to find the right frequency that works for your audience. You can start by analyzing your email performance data and identifying the sweet spot where engagement is highest.

How to avoid spamming your customers

Email spamming can lead to high unsubscribe rates, hurting your email marketing success. To avoid spamming, provide a clear and easy-to-find unsubscribe button in your emails. Also, segment your email list to ensure you’re sending relevant content to your subscribers.

In summary, timing, and frequency are crucial for email marketing success. By understanding your audience, testing and optimizing your email campaigns, you can send the right message at the right time, and avoid being spammy.

Measuring Success

Etsy email marketing can be a powerful tool for Etsy sellers, but how do you know if it’s actually working for you? In this section, we’ll cover the key metrics to track and best practices for measuring your email marketing success.

The key metrics to track for Etsy email marketing

To effectively measure the success of your email marketing efforts, you need to track the right metrics. Here are the key metrics to keep an eye on:

  • Open rates: The percentage of recipients who open your emails.
  • Click-through rates: The percentage of recipients who click on links in your emails.
  • Conversion rates: The percentage of recipients who take a desired action, such as making a purchase or signing up for a newsletter.
  • Unsubscribe rates: The percentage of recipients who unsubscribe from your emails.
  • Revenue generated: The total amount of revenue generated from your email campaigns.

Looking to improve your Etsy email marketing? 

Download our Email Performance Metrics Table to track key metrics for each of your email campaigns, such as open rates, click-through rates, conversion rates, and revenue generated.

Best practices for A/B testing your emails

A/B testing can help you improve your email marketing by allowing you to test different elements of your emails to see what works best. Here are some best practices for A/B testing your emails:

  • Test one element at a time: To accurately measure the impact of each change, only test one element at a time, such as the subject line or call-to-action.
  • Use a large enough sample size: Make sure your sample size is large enough to produce statistically significant results.
  • Have a clear hypothesis: Before you start testing, have a clear hypothesis about what you expect to happen and why.
  • Test regularly: Make A/B testing a regular part of your email marketing strategy to continually improve your campaigns.

How to use data to optimize your email campaigns

Tracking metrics and A/B testing are important, but it’s what you do with the data that really matters. Here’s how you can use data to optimize your email campaigns:

  • Analyze your data regularly: Regularly review your email marketing metrics and use them to inform your strategy going forward.
  • Adjust your approach based on the data: If you find that certain subject lines or types of content are performing better than others, adjust your approach accordingly.
  • Personalize your emails: Use customer data to personalize your emails and make them more relevant to each recipient.
  • Experiment with timing and frequency: Use your data to experiment with the timing and frequency of your emails to find what works best for your audience.

By following these best practices and using data to inform your approach, you can continually improve your email marketing and drive more sales on Etsy.

Compliance and Best Practices

Etsy’s policies on email marketing

Etsy has strict policies on email marketing to protect the privacy and security of their customers. According to their guidelines, you can only send marketing emails to customers who have opted-in to receive them. Sending unsolicited emails or adding customers to your email list without their consent can result in account suspension or termination.

Best practices for staying compliant with email marketing regulations

To avoid any issues with compliance, it’s essential to follow email marketing regulations such as the CAN-SPAM Act. The following are some best practices to keep in mind:

  • Only send emails to customers who have opted-in to receive them.
  • Clearly identify yourself as the sender of the email.
  • Include an unsubscribe link in your emails.
  • Honor unsubscribe requests immediately.
  • Don’t use misleading subject lines or false information in your emails.

How to avoid common email marketing mistakes

Even with the best intentions, email marketing mistakes can still happen. Here are some common mistakes to avoid:

  • Over-emailing

Sending too many emails can lead to unsubscribes and customers marking your emails as spam.

  • Poor segmentation

Not segmenting your email list can lead to irrelevant messages being sent to customers, decreasing engagement.

  • Lack of personalization

Personalization can increase open and click-through rates. Failing to include personalization can make your emails feel impersonal and generic.

  • Not testing

A/B testing can help you optimize your email campaigns. Failing to test can lead to missed opportunities for improvement.

By following best practices and avoiding common mistakes, you can build a successful email marketing campaign on Etsy while staying compliant with regulations.

Summing Up

Etsy email marketing is a powerful tool for Etsy shop owners to connect with their customers, build brand awareness, and increase sales. By following the best practices outlined in this guide, you can create effective email campaigns that engage your customers, drive traffic to your Etsy shop, and ultimately, boost your sales.

Remember to focus on building your email list, creating personalized and segmented emails, finding the optimal timing and frequency, tracking metrics, and complying with Etsy’s policies and email marketing regulations. By implementing these strategies, you can take your email marketing efforts to the next level and see real results for your Etsy shop.


Does Etsy offer email marketing?

Yes, Etsy does offer email marketing through its integrated email marketing tool called “Etsy Marketing.” This feature allows sellers to create and send promotional emails to their customers on Etsy.

How do I grow an email list on Etsy?

To grow an email list on Etsy, you can use various methods such as adding an email signup form to your shop, offering exclusive discounts or freebies for email subscribers, promoting your email list on social media, and including a call-to-action in your product listings.

Can you email customers from Etsy?

Yes, as an Etsy seller, you can email customers from the platform. You can use the “Conversations” feature to communicate with buyers and discuss order details or provide customer support. However, you should not use this feature for promotional purposes as it goes against Etsy’s policies.

Can you use MailChimp with Etsy?

Yes, you can use MailChimp with Etsy by integrating your Etsy shop with your MailChimp account. This allows you to automatically add new customers to your MailChimp email list and send targeted email campaigns. You can also use MailChimp to create customized email templates and automate your email marketing efforts.

Get your hands on my ultimate spreadsheet with 60+ Google Search Operators by signing up below!

* indicates required
Scroll to Top